So what's your rating - a "1", maybe an "8", or is it an "A", no wait I have it "Somewhat agree", or even better "Outstanding"? These are some of the terms that Dark Age companies use in their performance appraisals. Also included in the dark ages are performance evaluations that are done only annually. Groups of people sit around and try to rate each other and then try to come to some "supposedly mutual" agreement. These types of performance appraisals waste a lot of time. People walk out of them with no buy in and everyone is waiting for next year.
The human species needs feedback whether it is good or bad. So much of who we are is related to what others think about us. We need to know how we fit into the groups we are involved with.
I am a supporter of the Theory Y school that believes that people want to inherently learn, seek individual growth, and perform well in the work place. I believe that we all do things well and that we all could improve in some area.
If your company practices open book management, includes your employees in strategic planning, shares the organization's wealth (through an ESOP or some other form of employee ownership), and practices some form of process improvement, consider a new performance appraisal system. I would suggest one called the 3/3.
It is a one page feedback form that is used between two people or by a group. It serves as a guide for a "good conversation," (like in Tom Cruise's movie The Last Samurai.) It contains only three items:
- What are the things you do well that enhance our working relationship and/or the company?
- What are the things you could improve on to make our working relationship and/or the company better?
- This is my commitment to you.
The human in us is now fed with the acknowledgment of what we do well, increased awareness for growth, and a personal commitment to relationships.
I was a part of this performance appraisal system for five years - it works. The form could be used by all areas, between areas, across responsibility roles and whenever anyone wanted to use it. If you would like to discuss this concept in more detail, contact me at your convenience.
Technorati Tags: business communications, performance appraisals, feedback